Blog

  • Internet Archive Faces Copyright Lawsuit Over ‘Myspace Dragon Hoard’

    Internet Archive Faces Copyright Lawsuit Over ‘Myspace Dragon Hoard’

    Through its non-profit organization, the Internet Archive (IA) aims to preserve digital history for generations to come.

    The Archive’s popular Wayback Machine has archived decades of web history, and it also aims to preserve content directly: by scanning physical books or recording old gramophones, for example.

    One of the more unique preservation projects centers around Myspace, which was the leading social network twenty years ago. The site was particularly popular among musicians, but today it’s a shell of its former self with virtually no new activity. In fact, quite a bit of content was permanently lost.

    The Myspace Dragon Hoard

    In March 2019, Myspace publicly announced that all music uploaded to the platform between 2003 and 2015 had been wiped. As the result of a failed server migration, an estimated 50 million songs from 14 million artists were gone.

    Days later, Internet Archive employee Jason Scott announced on X that some files may have been preserved. An anonymous academic group had mailed him a hard drive containing roughly 490,000 of those recordings, scraped from Myspace between 2008 and 2010.

    “ANNOUNCING THE MYSPACE MUSIC DRAGON HOARD, a 450,000 song collection of mp3s from 2008-2010 on Myspace, gathered before they were all ‘deleted’ by mistake,” Scott posted at the time.

    The tweet

    tweet

    This collection was uploaded to archive.org and made available for free, allowing people to stream and download the music without any limits. In addition, an unnamed entity launched a companion site, lostmyspace.com, with a dedicated search and playback interface for the archived files.

    ‘Myspace Dragon Hoard’

    dragon hoard

    With key historical data safely stored, the Myspace preservation effort was celebrated widely. However, not everyone was pleased.

    Musician Sues Internet Archive

    Two years ago, the Illinois-based musician Anthony Martino found out that several of his songs were part of the Myspace Dragon Hoard. These files were hosted by the Internet Archive without his permission and formed the basis of a legal challenge.

    Last December, Martino filed a copyright infringement complaint in federal court. He argues that the recordings from his Myspace should not have been included to begin with, as he made these inaccessible to the public around 2011, long before Myspace lost the data.

    An amended complaint, filed in January, accuses Internet Archive of copyright infringement, requesting the maximum statutory damages of $150,000 per work for willful infringement.

    In addition to 11 works in the Myspace database, Martino also claims IA scanned and digitized his physical CD liner notes and printed lyrics, adding 48 additional works to the mix. This puts the (theoretical) maximum damages at $8,850,000.

    However, in its answer, Internet Archive pointed out that potential damages should be reduced to the statutory minimum, as low as $200 per work, because any infringement was innocent. That would put the damages floor at roughly $11,800.

    Internet Archive: We Didn’t Upload Anything

    The Internet Archive vehemently disputes the copyright infringement claims. The organization explains that it was not directly involved in uploading the ‘Myspace Dragon Hoard’. IA notes that this was done by the anonymous academic researchers that were mentioned earlier.

    “A group of academics that had saved some of the lost materials uploaded their archive onto the Internet Archive’s website,” the Archive’s attorney informed the court in a joint case management statement last week, noting that the organization is protected against third-party claims by the DMCA safe harbor.

    IA does not see any outstanding issues and says that, to its understanding, all of Martino’s takedown DMCA requests were eventually processed.

    In its formal answer to the complaint, Internet Archive also raises a notable counter-argument: it denies that any license Martino granted to Myspace by uploading his recordings was “fully and immediately revocable,” and denies that such a license prohibited distribution to third parties outside Myspace’s platform.

    Martino, meanwhile, remains convinced that IA has a more active role. Among other things, he points to public statements by Scott himself describing his role in coordinating the collection’s upload.

    To Trial

    Since the case will move forward to trial, both parties will get the chance to conduct discovery to find evidence for their claims. The eventual trial date has not been scheduled yet, but both parties suggest planning it for April of 2027.

    This is not the first music copyright dispute the Internet Archive is involved in. The organization was previously sued by several major music labels for digitizing gramophones. This case was settled confidentially last September.

    A copy of Martino’s amended complaint is available here (pdf). The Internet Archive’s answer can be found here (pdf), while the case management statement is here (pdf).

    From: TF, for the latest news on copyright battles, piracy and more.

  • Maternity inquiry chair named in government U-turn

    Donna Ockenden is appointed to lead the maternity services inquiry at Leeds hospitals.
  • Kyrgyz High Court Overturns Six-Year Sentence for Anti-Corruption Reporter

    The Kyrgyz Supreme Court on Tuesday overturned the six-year prison sentence of an independent investigative journalist and ordered a new trial. The move came after months of mounting international pressure.

    Investigative reporter Makhabat Tazhibek kyzy, a reporter for the investigative outlet Temirov Live, will have her case sent back to a lower court. Until the ruling, she was the only journalist from the outlet still behind bars following a sweeping crackdown on the press.

    Tazhibek kyzy and 10 former colleagues were detained during police raids in January 2024 and accused of inciting and organizing mass riots. Rights groups and colleagues maintain the charges were retaliation for the outlet’s reporting on high-level corruption in the Central Asian nation. Tazhibek kyzy was convicted and sentenced in October 2024.

    The Supreme Court’s decision to review the case and resume proceedings follows intense lobbying by international bodies. In November 2025, the U.N. Working Group on Arbitrary Detention publicly called on Kyrgyz authorities to immediately release Tazhibek kyzy and cease a campaign of intimidation against independent media. Earlier, in April 2025, the U.N. Human Rights Office urged the government to review the convictions and remove conditional sentences imposed on the reporters.

    Bolot Temirov, editor-in-chief of Temirov Live—a partner of the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project—said the U.N. intervention heavily influenced the court’s review of his wife’s case.

    “Based on the decision of the U.N. working group as a whole, the court began its consideration,” Temirov told the OCCRP. “The U.N. working group’s conclusion presents all the arguments and evidence that this was an illegal arrest and unlawful criminal prosecution. Well, that’s better than nothing.”

    Of the 11 journalists originally detained, colleague Azamat Ishenbekov was also sentenced to prison but was later pardoned by the president. Two others, Aktilek Kaparov and Aike Beishekeeva, were released on probation, while the remaining journalists were acquitted due to a lack of evidence.

    The prosecution of the Temirov Live journalists has prompted international condemnation, with organizations including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and Reporters Without Borders accusing Kyrgyzstan of a concerted effort to muzzle free speech.

  • Malaysia Smashes Cross-Border Scam Ring, Deports 16 to China

    Malaysia’s anti-corruption agency has arrested 16 Chinese nationals wanted by Beijing for allegedly operating a cross-border fraud network, state news agency Bernama reported.

    The suspects have already been repatriated to China to stand trial following a crackdown on the scam center, Zamri Zainul Abidin, a senior director at the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC), told Bernama.

    During the raid, MACC officials seized approximately 3.5 million ringgit ($890,000) in assets, including gold bars, foreign currency, and two luxury vehicles.

    Authorities also confiscated laptops and mobile phones suspected of being used as the primary tools for the syndicate’s fraudulent operations.

  • Nicaragua: Rights experts uncover State corruption fuelling repression, spying on exiles

    Nicaragua’s Government is financing the repression of its opponents through illegal misuse of public funds and targeting exiles through a transnational surveillance and intelligence network, the UN Group of Independent Human Rights Experts on Nicaragua warned in its latest report on Tuesday.
  • ‘Toxic rain’ warning from oil depot strikes amid ongoing Middle East war

    Toxic “black rain” linked to strikes on oil depots, mass displacement and continuing disruption to aid supply chains are upending lives across the Middle East and beyond after 10 days of war in the region, UN humanitarians said on Tuesday. 
  • From Wagner to GRU, Russian Military Men Are Manning Moscow’s Shadow Fleet

    On December 27, 2025, the sanctioned oil tanker Kira K was docked in the Russian port of Ust-Luga, deep within the eastern reaches of the Gulf of Finland. It was preparing to haul 734,000 barrels of crude oil belonging to Lukoil, the blacklisted Russian energy giant, out to the global market. 

    According to the ship’s crew list, the vessel was manned by a mix of sailors from Myanmar, China, and Bangladesh.

    But there were two other men on board as well. The tanker’s crew manifest lists Russian citizens Denis Enin and Aleksandr Kamenev as “supernumeraries” — a term for personnel who fall outside the standard operating crew.

    In the data fields detailing each crew member’s seafarer diplomas and qualifications, only two letters appear next to the Russian names: NA. Not available.

    That is because these men are not your normal sailors. 

    Kamenev, 45, and Enin, 48, are both veterans of the Wagner Group, the notorious Russian mercenary outfit that fought in conflicts around the world on Moscow’s behalf for nearly a decade until 2023. 

    Kamenev was in Syria and Russian-occupied Donetsk during the height of Wagner’s operations there, leaked border crossing data shows. Enin, for his part, has listed his registered address as that of a military unit in southern Russia. 

    The two men’s presence on the Kira K is not incidental. A joint investigation by Delfi, Helsingin Sanomat, iStories, and OCCRP has identified a systematic pattern of militarizing Russia’s so-called shadow fleet, the term used to describe the hundreds of aging and opaquely owned vessels that Moscow uses to circumvent Western sanctions on its oil. 

    By analyzing crew lists from sanctioned tankers across 20 journeys, reporters found that vessels departing Russia’s Baltic Sea ports now regularly carry two-man teams with military backgrounds. 

    Of the 17 Russian men aboard these ships who lacked maritime credentials, 13 were found to have links to the Wagner Group or state security organizations such as Russia’s military spy service, the GRU. Reporters established these connections through an array of leaked Russian databases, a registry of Wagner mercenaries from 2021, and information gathered from European intelligence agencies and open sources.   

    These extra crewmen or “technicians,” as they are sometimes referred to, started appearing on vessels after July 2025, according to the crew lists obtained by reporters. They are notably absent from a limited sample of crew manifests for vessels traveling Black Sea or Pacific routes during the same period, suggesting a targeted presence in the Baltic Sea.

    The findings add new evidence to warnings from Western intelligence agencies, first reported by CNN late last year, that Russians with security backgrounds were boarding Moscow’s shadow fleet tankers and engaging in spying near European shores. The crew manifests indicate the scale and systematic nature of the phenomenon, and provided names and other identifiers that allowed reporters to confirm the men’s military pasts.

    Intelligence sources from multiple European countries told reporters that these so-called “vessel protection teams” have been deployed to deter authorities from Baltic Sea nations from boarding, inspecting, or potentially seizing the ships that form an economic lifeline for Moscow. 

    European authorities generally cannot stop such vessels solely for being sanctioned. But they have in the past year halted tankers belonging to Russia’s shadow fleet on a handful of occasions, often for flying a false flag or for being suspected of damaging undersea cables.

    But with battle-hardened veterans on board, any such intervention could risk facing an armed resistance.  

    “The goal of this activity is to protect the Russian Federation’s revenue base from potential threats, be it [Ukraine-organized] sabotage” or other interference from the West, the head of Estonian Defense Forces Intelligence Center, Colonel Ants Kiviselg, told Delfi. 

    “Placing ship protecting crews on these ships shows that the goods moved by the shadow fleet and the revenue derived from them are important to Russia,” he added. 

    Russia relies heavily on the Baltic route to transport oil that generates millions in revenue for the state’s war chest on a daily basis. According to the Kyiv School of Economics, the country exports roughly 40 percent of its crude oil specifically through the Baltic Sea.

    But some analysts believe the special crew members appearing on the Baltic route have been deployed to do more than secure Russia’s economic interests. 

    Glen Grant, a defense advisor and a former U.K. defense attaché to Estonia and Latvia, noted that by sailing through the Baltic unimpeded, these former military men are also able to gather valuable information, including how Western authorities engage with the sanctioned tankers. 

    “Collectively that gives them a complete idea of our strength, resolve, philosophy and our military capability,” he said. “The fact that they’re carrying oil and that they get money in [for Russia] as well is a bonus.”

    Russia’s Ministry of Defense, Lukoil, and the company managing the Kira K did not respond to questions sent by reporters. When reached on Telegram, Enin, one of the Russians listed as part of the Kira K’s crew, denied having been aboard the ship and did not answer further questions. His compatriot Kamenev did not respond to questions sent to his email. 

    A Paratrooper and an Intelligence Officer

    The Russian crewmen identified by reporters are not just affiliated with the Wagner group, which is accused by the EU of carrying out grave rights abuses everywhere from Ukraine to Syria and the Central African Republic. (The organization was effectively disbanded after its leader Yevgeny Prigozhin staged a failed rebellion in June 2023, and then died in a plane crash two months later).  

    The shadow fleet crews also include Russians from a range of other military backgrounds, such as Aleksandr Malakhov, a “supernumerary” who rode on the Kira K in October 2025. 

    The 50-year-old is a veteran of the 22nd Spetsnaz Brigade, a special forces unit under the Russian military intelligence service known as the GRU, a European intelligence source confirmed to reporters. (Leaked data also shows Malakhov’s registered address was listed as the Spetsnaz unit in southern Russia’s Rostov Oblast). He did not respond to questions sent to his email address. 

    In August 2025, the Kira K carried another Russian duo through the Gulf of Finland: 50-year-old Dmitry Frolov and 38-year-old Juri Tsvetkov. Reporters found these two men have been travel companions before. In both 2022 and 2023, the pair flew together on Russian Air Force aircraft, according to leaked Russian border crossing data. 

    When contacted on Telegram, Frolov denied having been at sea. After reporters said they possessed proof he was present on the Kira K, he wrote: “Forget it, don’t write. Otherwise, I’ll turn [you] in to the FSB.” His shipmate Tsvetkov did not respond to questions sent to his email address. 

    Another sanctioned tanker known as the Lebre, meanwhile, has carried “technicians” who worked for the Russian Ministry of Defense and the Ministry of Defense of the Russia-backed breakaway territory of Transnistria, according to information provided by the Foreign Intelligence Service of Ukraine, which said it was in possession of the men’s employment records. 

    When reached for comment, the crewman linked to Russia’s defense ministry denied ever having been employed there, and said he had worked on the tanker as a cook. He confirmed that the other Russian on board who was also listed as a technician had, however, served as a guard. That crewman did not respond to requests to comment. 

    The ship’s manager, Anchor Elite Shipmanagement, said it was “not in a position to confirm the allegations presented” about the men, but that their presence on the ship was “in no way connected with military or private military activities,” and they were engaged solely in “galley duties” and “deck-related work.”

    Another shadow fleet vessel, which made headlines when it was seized by French authorities in September 2025, has also carried a paratrooper serving in the Russian Army, according to an intelligence officer in the Baltic Sea region, who spoke on the condition of anonymity due to the sensitivity of information provided. 

    Reporters found that a Russian with the same name and date of birth, Stanislav Babichev, has a profile on a social media platform that lists a military training school — 332 Airborne Forces Warrant Officer School — as his education. He did not respond to questions sent to his email address.

    An analyst with the Finnish Security and Intelligence Service (SUPO) said that these Russian security teams are likely tasked with preventing the rest of their ship’s crew from complying with foreign authorities.

    “The guards are likely on board to ensure that other Baltic Sea countries do not take control of these ships too easily,” the analyst told Helsingin Sanomat on the condition of anonymity.

    They also may act as “liaisons” for those who hired them, the analyst added. “It can be assumed that if, for example, Russian military forces and naval vessels are operating in the same area and escorting these ships, then the task of these men may be to facilitate communication.” 

    Ukraine’s Foreign Intelligence Service told reporters these men are typically hired by the Russian private security companies RSB Group and Moran Security Group.

    RSB Group, whose website says it has “protected tens of merchant and scientific Russian and foreign vessels,” employs former Russian intelligence officers and other combatants, and has trained units for the war in Ukraine, according to EU and U.S sanctions notices. Moran Security, which also offers a variety of maritime protection services on its website, has also been sanctioned by the U.S. for providing services to Russian state enterprises.

    The companies did not respond to requests to comment. 

    Raising the Stakes

    The deployment of these covert security agents on commercial vessels comes amid a marked increase in Russia’s direct military presence in the Baltic. 

    Last May, the Estonian Navy escorted the EU-sanctioned oil tanker Jaguar out of Estonian economic waters after it was found to be sailing without a valid flag.  

    Russia responded by sending a fighter jet that violated Estonian airspace.  

    “Russia sees the shadow fleet as a very important economic lever,” said Estonian Navy Commander Ivo Värk, adding Russia’s naval presence in the Baltic has quadrupled since 2022. 

    “For them, it is a matter of high national interest. Russia is prepared to protect this by all means.” 

    A high-ranking European intelligence officer who spoke on the condition of anonymity said the presence of security officials on the ships raises the stakes of any efforts to intervene in Russia’s oil trade. 

    “Two potentially armed individuals certainly changes [our] risk calculus when we must decide whether to stop or seize the tanker. Russia believes this makes NATO member states along the Baltic Sea more cautious,” the official said. 

    For Sean Wiswesser, a former CIA senior operations officer with a specialization in the Russian intelligence services and military, the trend suggests Moscow is also using its shadow fleet vessels as platforms for “sabotage” and “other intelligence operations, like potentially deploying drones.”

    “It’s definitely not just about protecting Russia’s oil,” he said. “Nowhere else in the world have there been as many cable cuts, and in a short time, as there have been in the past two years in the Baltic Sea.”

    Additional reporting by Kaur Maran, Greete Palgi, Marta Vunš (Delfi).

  • March 15 is the deadline to apply for LibreLocal funding

    If you want funding for your meetup, apply before it’s too late!